I know I’ve written about having boys in the past, but it continues to be a source of fascination and confusion for me to be mother to two of them. One of the most difficult realizations I have had to make is that when I am watching a group of boys in action, I am utterly at a loss of how to interpret what I see. What I think I see is a group of mean, wild animals. I see two boys grab another boy, whip him around and fling him down. I see that boy (perhaps my son) get up fiercely and grab one of the perpetrators and spin him and toss him to the ground. I see those same boys chase another and tackle him to the ground. “How horrible!” I think. I must intervene. They must be miserable and someone is sure to get hurt! But then, just as I feel confident that I have assessed the situation accurately and that someone must intervene, I see all the boys involved laughing, and then my son, who I thought might be scarred for life by the mistreatment, literally skipping away with a big smile on his face. I listen to friends with older boys say, “oh, I don’t get involved unless there’s blood.”
“Okay,” I think. “I didn’t really read that situation correctly. I guess they like playing that way, I guess that’s their idea of fun.” The next time I see similar play I feign a laid-back attitude. “Oh sure,” I tell myself, “that’s just the way boys play, they love this kind of thing.” I stand back and smile as I watch the boys pounce on each other. But wait! There’s a boy crying, he got hurt. “I want to go home!” I hear him shriek. Once again, I got it wrong. I truly never, ever know whether what I see when boys play is: a) really great; b)okay, but could turn ugly; or c) horrible and requires intervention right away.
It’s more challenging for me because even though my oldest, Jasper, is almost seven, I’ve really only see boys play like this for the last year or so. Prior to this, most of his playmates were girls. His basic nature is very calm, so watching him enter this world and interact with it fills me with trepidation. Deep down I don’t feel that he’s really equipped to deal with all the roughness, especially when so many of the boys are older than him, but it’s interesting to see that he more or less stands his ground. It’s also been interesting to observe that when things get really rough, he tends to go off on his own. This happened today, and when I saw him off, way off, playing by himself, I went over to him, sure he would be upset and wanting to go home. When he saw me he said, “we don’t have to go home now, do we?” “No,” I tried to say casually. “Because I’m having fun and don’t want to go yet.” I wasn’t prepared for what he said, but didn’t want him to know what I had been thinking because I didn’t want to influence the situation. He told me that two boys tried to throw him in the bushes, and two tried to defend him. He said that one kid in particular is always mean. We discussed various possible ways of handling the situation. He didn’t really seem upset though, just content to play on his own for a while. I was sad that although there was a big group of kids playing together, he was alone. I was worried that maybe he wasn’t fitting in. My husband had a different take on it—he thinks it’s great that Jasper isn’t willing to be anyone’s punching bag. If it gets too mean or he’s the target of the cruelty, he would rather go off by himself.
I can appreciate his reasoning, but I do still wonder if he’s “fitting in” in the boy world. I wonder if he’s as tough as he needs to be. Honestly, I can’t, by observing, tell whether he is or not.
I know I won’t worry about Hugo as much. He’s almost four and seems to instinctively love the rough and tumble play. He always leaps on top of the boy pile, even if the kids are four or five years older than him. He has a high tolerance for pain and doesn’t seem to take things personally. I know I’ll be more used to this kind of play as he gets older too.
It always makes me wonder though, as the kids get older, will it be more of the same? I think of how girls have deep friendships and share their feelings. I see how Jasper has deep friendships with his female friends. I have never understood male friendships, but it sort of seems like they hang out and do activities and beat on each other, and then, over time, decide who the “good guys” are that they really like and trust. I will never be part of that world, but I do hope that over time I can watch them interact, and understand a little more about what I’m seeing. Maybe I would get a little more sleep.